Saturday, November 21, 2026
OurWeek

in Grant County, Indiana

The week's best of Grant County, in your inbox every Sunday morning — free.

Subscribe

Reports · Grant County, IN

The History of 709 West Spencer Avenue

Built about 1891 for Clarinda H. Armstrong and held by one family for 129 years: a Marion house told through the clippings, maps and records that survive.

Updated November 21, 2026

Tap to enlarge 709 West Spencer Avenue in 2025. Grant County Assessor, property record photograph, August 12, 2025.

709 West Spencer Avenue in 2025.

709 West Spencer Avenue in 2025. Grant County Assessor, property record photograph, August 12, 2025.

In November 1891 Clarinda H. Armstrong paid Robert J. Spencer $500 for half of a building lot on Marion's newest residential street. About a year later she was hosting dinners in her new house there. Her daughter was married in its front parlor in 1894, and her daughter's descendants lived in or held the house until 2020.

This report traces that history through the newspapers, maps, census returns and public records that survive. The clippings are the evidence; the notes under each one point out what to look for. Full citations are at the end.

Download the illustrated 29-page PDF edition

The house at a glance

  • Address709 West Spencer Avenue, Marion. Printed as "709 Spencer avenue" from 1894 until the "West" appears in the late 1990s.
  • BuiltAbout 1891–92, by the documents. The county record card says 1900; real-estate sites say 1959 or 1969, which is an appraisal "effective year," not the age.
  • Historic nameClarinda Sims Armstrong House, in the 1993 Grant County Interim Report of the Indiana Historic Sites and Structures Inventory.
  • StyleTwo-story frame house recorded as Queen Anne; hipped roof with cross gables and fish-scale shingles in the gables.
  • LotEast 44 feet of Lot 193, R. J. Spencer's Third Addition, platted December 1887.
  • One familyArmstrong and Sisson families, about 1892 to 2020: four generations and 129 years.

The land, 1885–1891

In 1885 Robert J. Spencer bought about 45 acres west of downtown Marion from the heirs of Greenup Holman and began dividing it into building lots. Spencer Avenue takes its name from him. His Third Addition, with lots on both sides of the avenue, was approved by the town board in December 1887.

Tap to enlarge The town board approves the plat, the legal start of the lot the house stands on. Marion Daily Chronicle, December 13, 1887, p. 3.

The town board approves the plat, the legal start of the lot the house stands on.

The town board approves the plat, the legal start of the lot the house stands on. Marion Daily Chronicle, December 13, 1887, p. 3.

Look for: "The plat of Robert J. Spencer's third addition to the town of Marion was presented and approved."

Tap to enlarge The Third Addition on the map one year after its approval, with lots drawn and no buildings shown. Frank M. Baldwin, Map of Marion, Ind. (1888), detail. Indiana University Libraries.

The Third Addition on the map one year after its approval, with lots drawn and no buildings shown.

The Third Addition on the map one year after its approval, with lots drawn and no buildings shown. Frank M. Baldwin, Map of Marion, Ind. (1888), detail. Indiana University Libraries.

Natural gas made the boom. Marion's first successful gas well came in 1887, and land speculators, well drillers, craftsmen and laborers followed. The town roughly doubled in the decade the house was built; the federal census counted fewer than 9,000 residents in 1890 and just over 17,000 in 1900. By 1891 the Chronicle reported that Spencer Avenue lots that sold for $250 when the addition was platted were worth $800 to $1,000, and that new houses there cost from $2,500 to $5,000.

Tap to enlarge Spencer Avenue in the building boom of 1891. The Marion Chronicle, October 16, 1891, p. 1.

Spencer Avenue in the building boom of 1891.

Spencer Avenue in the building boom of 1891. The Marion Chronicle, October 16, 1891, p. 1.

Look for: "Probably no residence property in the city has increased so much in value in the last few years as that of the Spencer addition and along the avenue."

Three weeks later the paper's weekly list of real-estate transfers recorded the sale that begins this house's history.

Tap to enlarge The founding sale. Marion Daily Chronicle, November 5, 1891, p. 1, "Transfers."

The founding sale.

The founding sale. Marion Daily Chronicle, November 5, 1891, p. 1, "Transfers."

Look for: "Robert J Spencer to Clarinda H Armstrong, e ½ lot 193 Spencer's 3d add Marion … $500." The price matches an empty building lot on the avenue at the time.

A home on Spencer Avenue, 1891–1894

No contract notice for the house has been found, but the newspapers show Mrs. Armstrong at home on Spencer Avenue barely a year after she bought the lot. In December 1892 her Chautauqua study club planned its Christmas dinner "at the home of Mrs. Armstrong on Spencer avenue."

Tap to enlarge The earliest notice found of Mrs. Armstrong's home on the avenue. Marion Daily Chronicle, December 19, 1892, p. 1.

The earliest notice found of Mrs.

The earliest notice found of Mrs. Armstrong's home on the avenue. Marion Daily Chronicle, December 19, 1892, p. 1.

Look for: The house number is not printed yet. The tie to Lot 193 rests on her ownership of that lot and on the later notices below.

Who was Clarinda Armstrong?

Clarinda Hazzard was born in 1839 in Henry County, Indiana, a daughter of Samuel Hazzard, who opened a store in New Castle in 1835. On November 13, 1862, she married Jacob Sims. The couple lived in Kokomo and later Indianapolis and had three children: a daughter, Nettie E. Sims, born in 1865, and twin sons. Jacob Sims and the twins died within three months of one another, about 1869, and Clarinda returned to New Castle.

On April 4, 1877, she married Dr. William G. Armstrong, a physician who had practiced in La Fontaine, Wabash County, since 1850. He died on January 20, 1881. After his death, her obituary says, she and her daughter "removed to Marion." Nettie appears in the Marion papers from December 1890, and in November 1891 her mother bought the lot on Spencer Avenue.

Jacob Sims had served in Company A, 137th Indiana Infantry, a "hundred days" regiment raised in 1864. On October 21, 1902, while living at 709 Spencer, Clarinda filed for a widow's pension on his service, and certificate no. 834,152 was issued. Between 1908 and 1914, private bills "granting a pension to Clarinda H. Armstrong" were introduced in Congress at least four times. The 1911 national directory of the Daughters of the American Revolution lists her as member no. 77480 at "709 Spencer av, Marion." Her lineage traces to two Revolutionary officers: Capt. Cord Hazzard of Haslet's Delaware Regiment and Capt. Thomas Woodward of the South Carolina Rangers.

Tap to enlarge Civil War pension index card: "Sims, Jacob … Widow: Armstrong, Clarinda H. … A, 137 Ind. Inf." General Index to Pension Files, 1861–1934 (NARA T288), via FamilySearch.

Civil War pension index card: "Sims, Jacob … Widow: Armstrong, Clarinda H.

Civil War pension index card: "Sims, Jacob … Widow: Armstrong, Clarinda H. … A, 137 Ind. Inf." General Index to Pension Files, 1861–1934 (NARA T288), via FamilySearch.

Look for: Her widow's claim, filed October 21, 1902 (application 772,222; certificate 834,152). The certificate number shows the pension was granted.

Nettie Sims was also at home on the avenue. In April 1894 the paper noted visitors who were "the guest of Miss Nettie Sims on Spencer avenue." Later that year the address itself appears in print: invitations went out in November 1894 for her marriage to James S. Sisson Jr., a bookkeeper at Willson's bank.

Tap to enlarge The first appearance of the number 709 found in print. Marion Leader-Tribune, November 22, 1894, p. 7.

The first appearance of the number 709 found in print.

The first appearance of the number 709 found in print. Marion Leader-Tribune, November 22, 1894, p. 7.

Look for: "…Wednesday evening, Nov. 28, at 7 p.m., at the residence, 709 Spencer avenue."

Tap to enlarge The wedding of Nettie E. Sims and James S. Sisson, November 28, 1894. The Marion Leader, December 7, 1894, p. 6.

The wedding of Nettie E.

The wedding of Nettie E. Sims and James S. Sisson, November 28, 1894. The Marion Leader, December 7, 1894, p. 6.

Look for: The ceremony was held "in the front parlor," and 116 guests "sat down to a most sumptuous supper." The couple returned from Chicago to "take up their residence with Mrs. Armstrong," the start of the shared Armstrong–Sisson household that held the house for generations.

The Armstrong–Sisson household, 1895–1925

Less than two months after the wedding the house nearly burned. With the family away for the evening, the kitchen stove overheated, set the floor beneath it on fire and fell through. As it fell it broke the water pipe, and the water put out the fire.

Tap to enlarge A kitchen fire, January 21, 1895. Marion Leader-Tribune, January 22, 1895, p. 5.

A kitchen fire, January 21, 1895.

A kitchen fire, January 21, 1895. Marion Leader-Tribune, January 22, 1895, p. 5.

Look for: "But for the breaking of the water pipe in the kitchen … her residence might today be a pile of ruins." The account names Mrs. Armstrong and "her son-in-law and daughter, Mr. and Mrs. James Sisson" as the household.

Through the following decades the house appears in the society columns as a meeting place for church and women's organizations, and now and then in the classified ads.

Tap to enlarge Christian Temple thimble social. Marion News-Tribune, April 8, 1898, p. 1.

Christian Temple thimble social.

Christian Temple thimble social. Marion News-Tribune, April 8, 1898, p. 1.
Tap to enlarge A household help-wanted notice. Marion Leader-Tribune, May 13, 1902, p. 5.

A household help-wanted notice.

A household help-wanted notice. Marion Leader-Tribune, May 13, 1902, p. 5.

The federal census confirms the household at this address. In 1900 James S. Sisson, his wife Nettie and Mrs. Armstrong were enumerated at 709 Spencer Avenue. By 1910 the home was recorded as owned, with a mortgage, and the household included the Sissons' son, Robert M. Sisson.

The house was also a place for the questions of the day. In February 1910 the Sissons hosted the Social Science Center for a paper on "Some Phases of the Woman Question," and in February 1913 the Advance Club met here for its election of officers and a debate on woman suffrage. In March 1919, during the influenza pandemic, the paper reported that Mrs. Sisson was "suffering with influenza, at her home" and improving.

Both women were active in the Daughters of the American Revolution. The first regular meeting of Marion's General Francis Marion chapter was held at the house in March 1910, and by 1913 Mrs. Armstrong was the chapter's regent.

Tap to enlarge The new D.A.R. chapter meets at the house. Marion Daily Chronicle, March 21, 1910, p. 5.

The new D.A.R.

The new D.A.R. chapter meets at the house. Marion Daily Chronicle, March 21, 1910, p. 5.

Look for: Hostess "Mrs. James Sisson of Spencer avenue, with her mother, Mrs. Clarinda H. Armstrong as the assistant hostess."

Tap to enlarge Mrs. Armstrong, chapter regent, presents the D.A.R. history-essay flag. Marion Daily Chronicle, February 26, 1913, p. 1.

Mrs.

Mrs. Armstrong, chapter regent, presents the D.A.R. history-essay flag. Marion Daily Chronicle, February 26, 1913, p. 1.

Look for: "Mrs. [Clarin]da H. Armstrong of No. 709 Spencer avenue, and regent of the local chapter, D.A.R."

The first fire-insurance map to cover this block was published by the Sanborn Map Company in January 1920. It shows a two-story frame dwelling on Lot 193 under the number 709, with a one-story front porch and a narrower rear wing. The 1931 revision adds a one-story garage behind the house.

Tap to enlarge 1920: the house on Lot 193, labeled 709, with no outbuilding. Sanborn Map Co., Marion, Ind., January 1920, sheet 27 (detail). Library of Congress.

1920: the house on Lot 193, labeled 709, with no outbuilding.

1920: the house on Lot 193, labeled 709, with no outbuilding. Sanborn Map Co., Marion, Ind., January 1920, sheet 27 (detail). Library of Congress.
Tap to enlarge 1931: the same house outline, with a garage behind it. Sanborn Map Co., Marion, Ind., January 1931, sheet 18 (detail). Library of Congress.

1931: the same house outline, with a garage behind it.

1931: the same house outline, with a garage behind it. Sanborn Map Co., Marion, Ind., January 1931, sheet 18 (detail). Library of Congress.

Look for: Lot 193 holds two houses on these maps, 709 on the east and 713/715 on the west. That matches today's legal description, the east 44 feet of Lot 193.

The Sissons' only child, Robert Mitchell Sisson, born in 1901 and raised at 709, graduated from Purdue University in 1923 with a degree in chemical engineering. He returned to Marion and the family real-estate and insurance business.

Tap to enlarge Robert Mitchell Sisson as a Purdue senior, 1923. The 1923 Debris (Purdue University yearbook), p. 103.

Robert Mitchell Sisson as a Purdue senior, 1923.

Robert Mitchell Sisson as a Purdue senior, 1923. The 1923 Debris (Purdue University yearbook), p. 103.

Look for: "Robert Mitchell Sisson, B.S. Ch.E., Marion, Indiana. Phi Gamma Delta; Gimlet; Catalyst; P.A.A.; Purdue Union."

Tap to enlarge A lost-and-found notice. Marion Leader-Tribune, April 30, 1922, p. 23.

A lost-and-found notice.

A lost-and-found notice. Marion Leader-Tribune, April 30, 1922, p. 23.

Look for: "A strand of graduated round delicate pink coral beads. Finder please return to Mrs. James Sisson, 709 Spencer Ave."

The Sisson years, 1925–1983

Clarinda H. Armstrong died at the house on March 16, 1925. Her obituary recalls a pioneer family: she was born in New Castle, and her grandfather, Ashael Woodward, was said to have been the first settler to plant corn in Henry County. According to family tradition recorded in 1995, the house was remodeled in 1924–25.

Tap to enlarge The death of the house's first owner. Marion Leader-Tribune, March 17, 1925, p. 6.

The death of the house's first owner.

The death of the house's first owner. Marion Leader-Tribune, March 17, 1925, p. 6.

Look for: She "died at the Sisson residence, 709 Spencer avenue." The obituary also tells of her marriage to Jacob Sims, the deaths of her husband and twin sons within three months, her second marriage to Dr. William Armstrong, and how "she and her daughter, now Mrs. Sisson, removed to Marion."

Tap to enlarge The next generation. Marion Leader-Tribune, February 26, 1926, p. 10.

The next generation.

The next generation. Marion Leader-Tribune, February 26, 1926, p. 10.

Look for: Invitations for the wedding of Thelma McElhaney of Warren to "Robert M. Sisson, son of Mr. and Mrs. James S. Sisson of Spencer avenue." Robert and Thelma Sisson were living at 709 by 1935, and Thelma remained there until her death in 1983.

Nettie Armstrong Sisson died in 1932 while undergoing treatment in Philadelphia; her funeral was held "from the family home, 709 Spencer avenue." James S. Sisson, a Marion real-estate man, died in August of the following year after a long illness at home.

Tap to enlarge Nettie A. Sisson, past regent of the Marion D.A.R. Marion Daily Chronicle, July 11, 1932, p. 1.

Nettie A.

Nettie A. Sisson, past regent of the Marion D.A.R. Marion Daily Chronicle, July 11, 1932, p. 1.
Tap to enlarge James S. Sisson, "seriously ill … at his home, 709 Spencer avenue." He died two days later. Marion Daily Chronicle, August 29, 1933, p. 2.

James S.

James S. Sisson, "seriously ill … at his home, 709 Spencer avenue." He died two days later. Marion Daily Chronicle, August 29, 1933, p. 2.

Robert M. Sisson, a realtor for nearly forty years, raised his own family in the house. The 1940 census records the home as owned and valued at $8,000, with the family in the "same house" as in 1935. He was also secretary-treasurer of the Washington Theater Corp., which owned the Lyric and Indiana theaters downtown. When the Lyric burned on January 24, 1939, Robert Sisson announced its rebuilding.

Tap to enlarge The Lyric Theater fire, front page of the morning after. The Marion Chronicle, January 25, 1939, p. 1.

The Lyric Theater fire, front page of the morning after.

The Lyric Theater fire, front page of the morning after. The Marion Chronicle, January 25, 1939, p. 1.

Look for: More than 300 patrons watching "Too Hot to Handle" got out safely. Further down: "According to Robert M. Sisson, secretary-treasurer of the Washington Theater Corp., owners of the building and equipment of both the Lyric and Indiana theaters, all loss is adequately covered by insurance."

Tap to enlarge Two bicycles stolen from the garage, the same garage first drawn on the 1931 map. Marion Leader-Tribune, July 19, 1938, p. 4.

Two bicycles stolen from the garage, the same garage first drawn on the 1931 map.

Two bicycles stolen from the garage, the same garage first drawn on the 1931 map. Marion Leader-Tribune, July 19, 1938, p. 4.
Tap to enlarge Firemen called to thaw frozen pipes at the Robert Sisson residence. Marion Leader-Tribune, December 18, 1951, p. 2.

Firemen called to thaw frozen pipes at the Robert Sisson residence.

Firemen called to thaw frozen pipes at the Robert Sisson residence. Marion Leader-Tribune, December 18, 1951, p. 2.

With two sons, Richard and Phillip, growing up in the house, the papers recorded the ordinary events of a family home in the 1940s.

Tap to enlarge Ten-year-old Phillip Sisson, a future owner of the house, is hurt in a fall at school. Marion Daily Chronicle, May 14, 1940, p. 2.

Ten-year-old Phillip Sisson, a future owner of the house, is hurt in a fall at school.

Ten-year-old Phillip Sisson, a future owner of the house, is hurt in a fall at school. Marion Daily Chronicle, May 14, 1940, p. 2.
Tap to enlarge A brewery's "careful driving" award names Robert Sisson of 709 Spencer Ave. Marion Leader-Tribune, February 20, 1947, p. 2.

A brewery's "careful driving" award names Robert Sisson of 709 Spencer Ave.

A brewery's "careful driving" award names Robert Sisson of 709 Spencer Ave. Marion Leader-Tribune, February 20, 1947, p. 2.
Tap to enlarge The Advance Club meets at 709 in a third generation. Marion Daily Chronicle, October 11, 1945, p. 4.

The Advance Club meets at 709 in a third generation.

The Advance Club meets at 709 in a third generation. Marion Daily Chronicle, October 11, 1945, p. 4.

Look for: The club met "at the home of Mrs. Robert Sisson, 709 Spencer avenue," and the gavel passed to Thelma Sisson as president. The same club had met at the house under Nettie Sisson as early as 1901.

Tap to enlarge Robert M. Sisson, 61, "veteran Marion realtor." Marion Leader-Tribune, December 23, 1962, p. 1.

Robert M.

Robert M. Sisson, 61, "veteran Marion realtor." Marion Leader-Tribune, December 23, 1962, p. 1.

Look for: A lifelong Marion resident and past president of the Marion Board of Realtors. His estate was opened in Grant Circuit Court in December 1962.

Tap to enlarge Thelma Sisson, 78, died "at her home," February 24, 1983. Marion Chronicle-Tribune, February 26, 1983, p. 12.

Thelma Sisson, 78, died "at her home," February 24, 1983.

Thelma Sisson, 78, died "at her home," February 24, 1983. Marion Chronicle-Tribune, February 26, 1983, p. 12.

Look for: She married into the family in 1926 and was living here by 1935. Like Clarinda Armstrong and Nettie Sisson before her, she was active in the city's women's organizations, including the Advance Club.

Preservation and change, 1983–today

Thelma Sisson's estate remained open for more than a decade, and the property appeared on Grant County's published lists of delinquent tax parcels in 1985 and 1988. It was absent from the 1987, 1989 and 1990 lists, and no tax deed has been found.

Tap to enlarge The county's 1988 delinquent-tax notice. Marion Chronicle-Tribune, September 12, 1988, p. 17, Legal Notices.

The county's 1988 delinquent-tax notice.

The county's 1988 delinquent-tax notice. Marion Chronicle-Tribune, September 12, 1988, p. 17, Legal Notices.

Look for: "Sisson Thelma … 709 Spencer Ave … 16-09-2150, 44′ E Side Lot 193, R J Spencers 3rd Add." The parcel key and legal description are the ones on the county record today.

In 1993 the Historic Landmarks Foundation of Indiana published the Grant County Interim Report of the Indiana Historic Sites and Structures Inventory. It recorded the house as the "Clarinda Sims Armstrong House," Queen Anne, c. 1900, a contributing building in the Spencer Avenue district. The surveyor's 1992 field photograph is the earliest known photograph of the house.

Tap to enlarge 709 West Spencer Avenue in 1992, photographed for the Indiana Historic Sites and Structures Inventory. Indiana DNR, Division of Historic Preservation and Archaeology, survey no. 053-384-34041.

709 West Spencer Avenue in 1992, photographed for the Indiana Historic Sites and Structures Inventory.

709 West Spencer Avenue in 1992, photographed for the Indiana Historic Sites and Structures Inventory. Indiana DNR, Division of Historic Preservation and Archaeology, survey no. 053-384-34041.

Look for: The original wood clapboard, before the later siding. The survey describes "shingles in gables, wide eaves with rafters and dentils," a "projecting porch with brick wall" and 6/1 windows, and rates the house "slightly altered." Note the railed deck over the garage at right.

Tap to enlarge The 1992 survey photograph, digitally colorized in 2026. The colors are conjectural; the original is black and white.

The 1992 survey photograph, digitally colorized in 2026.

The 1992 survey photograph, digitally colorized in 2026. The colors are conjectural; the original is black and white.

Thelma's younger son, Phillip R. Sisson (1930–2016), grew up in the house. A 1949 graduate of Marion High School, he was commissioned through ROTC at Indiana University in 1952, served in the Army and stayed in the Army Reserves for thirty years; his headstone in Marion National Cemetery reads "LTC, USA, Korea." On July 19, 1958, he married Margaret J. Webster (1936–2019) of Fowlerton. Like his father and grandfather he went into real estate, as a realtor and developer whose projects included Raintree Plaza and the Shady Hills Estates neighborhood. Margaret worked with him as a realtor and, with her sister-in-law, ran a Merle Norman cosmetics studio downtown and later at Raintree Plaza.

Between 1994 and 1995 title passed from Thelma's estate to Phillip, and he and Margaret moved into the house where he had grown up. The Chronicle-Tribune featured it on its front page, and in 1996 Margaret hosted her P.E.O. chapter there, a century after Nettie Sisson's clubs first met in the same rooms.

Tap to enlarge "Homes typify turn of century architecture." Marion Chronicle-Tribune, November 20, 1995, p. 1.

"Homes typify turn of century architecture." Marion Chronicle-Tribune, November 20, 1995, p.

"Homes typify turn of century architecture." Marion Chronicle-Tribune, November 20, 1995, p. 1.

Look for: The family's own account: the house "cost about $5,000 to build around 1890 and was remodeled between 1924 and 1925." Phillip Sisson said his great-grandmother and grandfather built it together: "I was told it was one of the first ones on top of the hill."

In November 1999 a stacked washer and dryer in an upstairs bathroom caught fire. Flames broke through the second-floor ceiling into the attic before firefighters contained them. Damage was estimated at $40,000, and the house was repaired.

Tap to enlarge The second fire in the house's history. Marion Chronicle-Tribune, November 11, 1999, p. 3.

The second fire in the house's history.

The second fire in the house's history. Marion Chronicle-Tribune, November 11, 1999, p. 3.

After Phillip R. Sisson's death in December 2016, title vested in his widow, Margaret J. Sisson, who died at her Marion home on December 21, 2019. She was the last of the family to own the house and, as far as the record shows, the last to live in it. Her estate conveyed the house to her heirs in June 2020, and in October 2020 they sold it, the first transfer outside the Armstrong–Sisson family found in the record.

Tap to enlarge 709 West Spencer Avenue in August 2025. Grant County Assessor, property record photograph, August 12, 2025.

709 West Spencer Avenue in August 2025.

709 West Spencer Avenue in August 2025. Grant County Assessor, property record photograph, August 12, 2025.

Look for: The steep hipped roof, front cross gable and fish-scale shingles in the gables are typical of 1890s houses. The square-columned porch differs from the full-width porch on the 1920 Sanborn map and may date from the 1924–25 remodel (unconfirmed). Since 1992 the clapboard has been covered with siding and the deck over the garage is gone.

Tap to enlarge Street view, October 2007. Google Street View.

Street view, October 2007.

Street view, October 2007. Google Street View.
Tap to enlarge Street view, August 2013. Google Street View.

Street view, August 2013.

Street view, August 2013. Google Street View.
Tap to enlarge Street view, July 2023. Google Street View.

Street view, July 2023.

Street view, July 2023. Google Street View.
Tap to enlarge Street view, April 2025. Google Street View.

Street view, April 2025.

Street view, April 2025. Google Street View.

Look for: The garage deck seen in 1992 is already gone by 2007. Camera color varies, so the changing siding tones are an observation, not a record of repainting.

Where they rest

Clarinda Armstrong and Nettie and James Sisson lie in the public mausoleum at the Marion I.O.O.F. Cemetery. Robert and Thelma Sisson are buried at Grant Memorial Park, and Phillip and Margaret Sisson at Marion National Cemetery. Clarinda's first and second husbands rest where her earlier lives were lived: an infant son of Jacob Sims at New Castle, and Dr. William G. Armstrong at La Fontaine.

Tap to enlarge Clarinda H. Armstrong, 1839–1925. Crypt front, public mausoleum C-33, Marion I.O.O.F. Cemetery. Find a Grave memorial 113605337.

Clarinda H.

Clarinda H. Armstrong, 1839–1925. Crypt front, public mausoleum C-33, Marion I.O.O.F. Cemetery. Find a Grave memorial 113605337.
Tap to enlarge Nettie E. Sisson, June 14, 1865 – July 10, 1932. Mausoleum D-33. Find a Grave memorial 106919693.

Nettie E.

Nettie E. Sisson, June 14, 1865 – July 10, 1932. Mausoleum D-33. Find a Grave memorial 106919693.
Tap to enlarge James S. Sisson, Feb. 6, 1868 – Aug. 31, 1933. Mausoleum D-34, beside Nettie. Find a Grave memorial 106919640.

James S.

James S. Sisson, Feb. 6, 1868 – Aug. 31, 1933. Mausoleum D-34, beside Nettie. Find a Grave memorial 106919640.
Tap to enlarge The public mausoleum at the Marion I.O.O.F. Cemetery. Find a Grave memorial 113605337.

The public mausoleum at the Marion I.O.O.F.

The public mausoleum at the Marion I.O.O.F. Cemetery. Find a Grave memorial 113605337.
Tap to enlarge Robert M. (1901–1962) and Thelma A. Sisson (1904–1983). Grant Memorial Park, plot B-788. Find a Grave memorial 90838009.

Robert M.

Robert M. (1901–1962) and Thelma A. Sisson (1904–1983). Grant Memorial Park, plot B-788. Find a Grave memorial 90838009.
Tap to enlarge Richard E. Sisson (1927–1993), Robert and Thelma's elder son, and his wife Delores. Find a Grave memorial 30300389.

Richard E.

Richard E. Sisson (1927–1993), Robert and Thelma's elder son, and his wife Delores. Find a Grave memorial 30300389.
Tap to enlarge Phillip R. Sisson, LTC, U.S. Army, Korea, 1930–2016, and Margaret J. Sisson, 1936–2019. Marion National Cemetery, section CC1-1. Find a Grave memorial 173820801.

Phillip R.

Phillip R. Sisson, LTC, U.S. Army, Korea, 1930–2016, and Margaret J. Sisson, 1936–2019. Marion National Cemetery, section CC1-1. Find a Grave memorial 173820801.
Tap to enlarge Reverse of the headstone: "Our hero among us." Find a Grave memorial 173820801.

Reverse of the headstone: "Our hero among us." Find a Grave memorial 173820801.

Reverse of the headstone: "Our hero among us." Find a Grave memorial 173820801.
Tap to enlarge Phillip R. Sisson in later life. Find a Grave memorial 173820801.

Phillip R.

Phillip R. Sisson in later life. Find a Grave memorial 173820801.
Tap to enlarge Margaret J. (Webster) Sisson. Find a Grave memorial 205699367.

Margaret J.

Margaret J. (Webster) Sisson. Find a Grave memorial 205699367.
Tap to enlarge "Infant Son of Jacob & Clarinda Hazzard Sims," South Mound Cemetery, New Castle. Find a Grave memorial 44872594.

"Infant Son of Jacob & Clarinda Hazzard Sims," South Mound Cemetery, New Castle.

"Infant Son of Jacob & Clarinda Hazzard Sims," South Mound Cemetery, New Castle. Find a Grave memorial 44872594.
Tap to enlarge Dr. William G. Armstrong's monument, Old La Fontaine Cemetery. Find a Grave memorial 13231413.

Dr.

Dr. William G. Armstrong's monument, Old La Fontaine Cemetery. Find a Grave memorial 13231413.
Tap to enlarge Dr. William G. Armstrong (1822–1881), engraved portrait. Find a Grave memorial 13231413.

Dr.

Dr. William G. Armstrong (1822–1881), engraved portrait. Find a Grave memorial 13231413.
Tap to enlarge Tintype of Dr. Armstrong, labeled in ink "Dr. Armstrong." Find a Grave memorial 13231413.

Tintype of Dr.

Tintype of Dr. Armstrong, labeled in ink "Dr. Armstrong." Find a Grave memorial 13231413.

Photographs from Find a Grave (findagrave.com), contributed by its volunteers and family members. The memorial numbers identify each source page.

Dating the house

Online real-estate sites give a construction date of 1959 or 1969. Those figures match the "effective year" on the county assessor's record card, an appraisal figure that reflects updates to the house, not its age. The card's own year built is 1900, a round figure the county also gives several neighboring houses. The documents point earlier.

The evidence, in order
DateEvidenceWhat it shows
Dec. 1887Plat of R. J. Spencer's Third Addition approvedLot 193 legally exists
1888Baldwin map shows the addition with no buildingsStreet and lots laid out
Nov. 5, 1891Spencer sells the east half of Lot 193 to Clarinda H. Armstrong for $500Ownership begins; price fits a vacant lot
Dec. 1892Club dinner "at the home of Mrs. Armstrong on Spencer avenue"A home on the avenue is occupied
Apr. 1894Visitors are "the guest of Miss Nettie Sims on Spencer avenue"Family living on the avenue
Nov. 1894Wedding "at the residence, 709 Spencer avenue"House standing at this number
Jan. 1895Kitchen fire put out; house savedSame house survives
1900–1950Federal census lists the family at 709 every decadeContinuous occupancy
1920–1952Sanborn maps show the same two-story frame outlineNo rebuilding in that period
1941–1969State aerial photographs show the block fully builtNo replacement around 1959
1995Family recalls construction "around 1890" for about $5,000Family account consistent with the record

Conclusion: a house stood at 709 Spencer Avenue by November 1894 (high confidence); it was most likely built in 1891–92 (medium-high); today's building is the original, not a replacement (medium-high). Still open: no building contract has been found, the 1887–1899 city directories have not been checked, and the deeds from 1904 to 1994 have not been examined at the Recorder's office.

Chain of title
DateTransferInstrument / note
1885Heirs of Greenup Holman → Robert J. SpencerAbout 45 acres, later platted
Nov. 5, 1891Robert J. Spencer → Clarinda H. ArmstrongEast ½ of Lot 193; $500
Aug. 1904R. J. Spencer → "C. I. Armstrong" (as printed)Additional part of Lot 193; $121
Apr. 9, 1910Warranty deed (parties not transcribed)Deed Record C, p. 479; likely Armstrong to Sisson (inferred)
1925–1983By inheritance through the Sisson family to Thelma A. SissonInferred from estates of 1925–1962
Jan. 27, 1994Estate of Thelma A. Sisson → Phillip R. Sisson et al.Personal representative's deed, instr. 33457
Jan. 12, 1995→ Phillip R. SissonPersonal representative's deed, instr. 36814
Sept. 25, 1995→ Phillip R. and Margaret J. SissonQuitclaim deed, instr. 38864
Nov. 15, 2000→ Phillip R. SissonQuitclaim deed, instr. 58606
Sept. 29, 2017Phillip R. Sisson → Margaret J. SissonAffidavit of heirship, instr. 2017-007250
June 10, 2020Estate of Margaret J. Sisson → her heirsPersonal representative's deed, instr. 2020-003948
Oct. 16, 2020Sisson heirs → Ryan E. KellermeyerWarranty deed, instr. 2020-007986

From newspaper transfer notices, the Grant County Auditor's transfer record and the county property record card. Instruments between 1904 and 1994 were not examined in the original.

Household of record, by census
YearHousehold at 709 Spencer AvenueTenure
1900James S. Sisson (bookkeeper), Nettie Sisson; Clarinda Armstrong (mother-in-law)Rented
1910James S. Sisson (insurance), Nettie E., Robert M.; Clarinda ArmstrongOwned, mortgaged
1920James Sisson (real estate), Nettie E., Robert M.; Clarinda H. ArmstrongOwned, mortgaged
1930James S. and Nettie E. SissonOwned, valued $8,000
1940Robert M. Sisson (real estate), Thelma A., and their childrenOwned, valued $8,000
1950Robert M. Sisson (real estate and insurance) and family—

Want the story of your house?

This report was compiled from newspapers back to the 1880s, fire-insurance maps, census returns, the state historic survey, and county deed, tax and court records. A history like this one, for any house in Grant County, is $100: a finished, illustrated report with the original clippings and full sources.

To order, email hello@ourweek.in with the address.

Download the illustrated 29-page PDF edition of this report

Print this report, or save it as a PDF — the documents open out on the page, and each recording carries a code that opens the video at the moment quoted.

Sources and methods

Compiled in November 2026 by Ryan Kellermeyer, the current owner of the house, from digitized newspapers on Newspapers.com, federal census schedules, Sanborn and county maps, the state historic survey, and Grant County public records. Each fact was checked against its source; items that rest on inference or family recollection are marked as such. Records not yet examined include the original deeds at the Grant County Recorder, the 1887–1899 Marion city directories and the state survey form. Corrections and additions, especially old photographs of the 700 block of Spencer Avenue, are welcome.

Get Grant County in your inbox

Reports like this one, plus the week's events, news and notices from Grant County, every Sunday morning.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. We don't share your info.